| Platinum | El Bosque |
| Gold | Angie's Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | Chuy's |
| Bronze | Mama Juanita's |
| Top Pick | El Tri Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Herreras Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mestizos Mexican Cafe |
| Top Pick | Rancho Grande Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Tapped DraftHouse & Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Zully's Latin American Kitchen |